Well the four weeks since the longlist was announced and us of the shadow jury have read and digest all the books on the longlist between us .I read the remaining nine books from the longlist I d not read before and have reviewed eight of them .So after we all scored the books partly for story and partly for translation for this first round we came up with the shadow shortlist which was chosen from seven books one missing out by a fraction of a point .Next round we will be discussing and not scoring the boos so here is our shortlist –
Parallel Stories by Peter Nadas translator Imre Goldstein .
Sex and violence behind in cold war era central Europe
Scenes From Village life by Amos Oz translator Nicholas De Lange
A Israeli village from the point of view of an old man
The Prague cemetery by Umberto Eco translator Richard Dixon
A master of evil pulls the stings in 19th century europe
From the mouth of the whale by Sjon translator Victoria Cribb
Birds whales and one chap in 17th century Iceland
Next world Novella by Mattihas Politycki translator Anthea Bell
Married is it what we think ,she dies he finds out
Seven Houses in france by Bernardo Atxaga translator Magaret Jull Costa
Heart of the Congo it is really dark .
So that is our fab six we will be choice our winner from this and also choosing a winner from the proper booktrust IFFP shortlist out tomorrow .Lets compare our lists then .
thanks to my fellow judges so far –
parrish lantern
Apr 11, 2012 @ 20:32:42
was some great books on this list, of the 7 I read although I had favourites, there wasn’t for me one that was total poop, they all had something going for them.Thanks for bringing me on board.
winstonsdad
Apr 23, 2012 @ 20:16:10
Great having you gary been real fun ,all the best stu
Gavin
Apr 12, 2012 @ 14:08:38
Thanks for the short list, Stu. Now I hope my library has some of these so I can read them!
winstonsdad
Apr 23, 2012 @ 20:13:14
welcome Gavin ,all the best stu
1streading
Apr 13, 2012 @ 19:30:26
I’ve read three from both the official and the shadow shortlist so it’s difficult to choose between them. I agree with parrish lantern, there’s not been a dud among the novels I’ve read so far.
winstonsdad
Apr 23, 2012 @ 20:12:56
Yes a strong list bar one for me ,all the best stu
markbooks
Apr 14, 2012 @ 10:43:31
I love our list so much more than the “proper” one!
winstonsdad
Apr 23, 2012 @ 20:12:16
Me too Mark but Ican see where there coming from ,all the best stu
Geosi
Apr 14, 2012 @ 13:07:33
Some pretty good reads.
winstonsdad
Apr 23, 2012 @ 20:11:46
Thanks Geosi ,all the best stu
Violet
Apr 15, 2012 @ 05:50:12
I’ve been championing Dream of Ding Village and am a little disappointed not to see it on your list. The Prague Cemetery is the only one I have read. I’m part-way through Sjon’s book, and have Oz’s on request at the library. The IFFP judges didn’t really agree with you guys, did they? 🙂
winstonsdad
Apr 23, 2012 @ 20:11:32
It was close Violet ,no I can see there list is there list and ours is ours after time thinking about it ,all the best stu